Tool · Household Systems

Rent-vs-Buy Calculator

Most rent-vs-buy calculators show you a monthly payment and stop. This one runs the full ledger, month by month for 30 years — interest, tax, insurance, maintenance, HOA, PMI, closing costs, selling costs, and the gain on the cash you did not spend at the door — and finds the month buying catches up, if it ever does. It is the same ledger as the site’s rent-vs-buy guide, with the math shown underneath.

The article's ledger, as a calculatorBreak-even to the monthRuns in your browserNothing saved or sent
Fills this tool with the worked examples it is tested against — illustrative numbers, not a recommendation. How we test

Renting is not throwing money away and buying is not automatically building wealth — both sides have a cost, and the ledger decides which is lower on your numbers. On the default example — a $385,000 home, 20% down, a 6.5% mortgage, $1,850 a month in rent — buying costs $199,109 over 10 years against renting’s $204,711, and the two sides cross in year 10. Change any number and watch the crossing move — or disappear.

1. The home and the loan

The rate is filled in from the latest Freddie Mac weekly survey — a starting point, not a quote. Replace it with the rate on your Loan Estimate. Rates move weekly; the survey figure is refreshed with it.

Term

The dollar and percent down-payment fields stay in sync — change one and the other follows. Drop below 20% and the PMI section below appears.

2. The monthly cost stack

Picking a state fills in that state’s average property-tax rate — a state average, not your county’s rate, and yours can differ by 2×. With no state chosen the tax starts at 1.1% of the price, the figure the rent-vs-buy guide uses. Insurance starts at 0.45% of the home price a year (the national average premium against the median home value) and follows the price until you type your own figure. Maintenance starts at 1% of the price a year — a planning figure, not a quote; older homes and harsh climates run higher, and the maintenance-reserve guide sizes it by component. Closing costs run 2%–5% of the price; selling costs have stayed around 5%–6% even after the 2024 NAR settlement, plus transfer taxes.

4. The rent side

Price the rental you would actually accept — not a palace against a studio. Renters insurance typically runs $10–$25 a month; leave it at $0 and the tool prices rent alone, the way the guide’s table does.

5. The assumptions

The investment return is what the down payment, the closing costs, and — if you turn on the toggle below — the monthly difference would earn if they stayed invested. It is a diversified-portfolio assumption, not a promise. The sensitivity table in the results shows what happens at ±1 point on each assumption.

When this is on, the side that costs less each month invests the difference at the return above, and the grown savings count against that side’s cost. It is the more complete model — and it favors renting whenever owning costs more than renting early on, which is the usual case. It is off by default so this tool agrees with the site’s rent-vs-buy guide, whose ledger does not invest the difference.

How this is calculated

The buy side is the Mortgage Calculator’s own math. The payment comes from the same amortization loop, month by month on the beginning balance, with the explicit final-payment adjustment — so the principal-and-interest, tax, insurance, and PMI lines on this page agree to the dollar with the Mortgage tool for the same loan. PMI comes from the same insurer rate cards and stops at the 80% request date.

The comparison is a total-cost ledger, month by month, for 30 years. Buying costs interest plus tax, insurance, maintenance, HOA, and PMI, plus closing costs at the door and selling costs at the exit, minus the appreciation on the home. Renting costs the rent, plus renters insurance if you enter it, minus the gain on the down payment and closing costs you did not spend at the door. Principal paid is not a cost — it is equity, and it is excluded by construction. The break-even is the first month where the buying total falls to or below the renting total, compared at each month-end, not only at year-ends.

Tax and maintenance are flat on the original price. That is the rent-vs-buy guide’s convention, kept so this tool agrees with the published table to the dollar. Tax and maintenance that rise with the home’s value would make buying look slightly worse — the direction is stated here because the convention is a choice, not a fact.

The 5% rule is shown with its limit, not as the verdict. The rule says owning costs about 5% of the price a year. On the default household the actual year-1 unrecoverable cost is $2,897 a month against the rule’s $1,604 — the rule assumes a roughly 3% cost of capital, and the mortgage is 6.5%.

What the ledger leaves out, on purpose. There is no mortgage-interest deduction in this version — including it would make buying look better, by an amount that depends on the reader’s bracket, so the direction is named and the deduction is a candidate for a later version. The renter does not invest the monthly difference unless you turn the toggle on.

Assumptions and sources

  • Rate prefill: the Freddie Mac Primary Mortgage Market Survey®, week of Nov 19, 2026 — average 30-year fixed 7.28%. Rates move weekly; the figure on this page is refreshed with the survey. It is a starting point, not a quote.
  • Property-tax estimates: Tax Foundation effective rates (2026 table, 2024 American Community Survey data), one rate per state plus the District of Columbia. The figure is a state average — your county and city rates can be well above or below it.
  • PMI rates: Arch MI’s borrower-paid monthly rate card (effective Feb. 9, 2026), cross-checked against MGIC’s rate bulletin (effective July 9, 2018). The rate is by credit band and loan-to-value; the tool’s band medians are the published cells.
  • Insurance default: 0.45% of the home price a year. The National Association of Insurance Commissioners’ latest average homeowners premium is $1,737 a year (2023 data, published July 2026) against a roughly $390,000 median home value — about 0.45%. Type your own premium when you have a quote; it governs.
  • Renters insurance: typically $10–$25 a month (NerdWallet’s 2026 average is about $14 a month). The guide’s table prices rent alone; the tool prices renters insurance separately, at $0 by default.
  • Selling costs: agent commissions have stayed around 5%–6% even after the 2024 NAR settlement, plus transfer taxes. The default 6% is the high end of that range.
  • What this tool does not model: the mortgage-interest deduction; tax on the investment gain; rent increases beyond the single growth rate you enter; moving costs; and the value of the flexibility renting buys — the guide’s line stands: renting buys flexibility at a price this ledger can compute.

Official documentation and references

Educational disclaimer: This calculator is general education, not personalized financial, tax, legal, or investment advice. These are estimates from the figures you enter — not a forecast, a guarantee, or a recommendation. Home prices, rents, rates, and tax figures all move, and the assumptions you enter (appreciation, rent growth, investment return) are the largest drivers of the answer — the sensitivity table exists because a one-point change in any of them can move the break-even by years. Nothing you type is saved or sent anywhere.

Keep going