Every rent-vs.-buy argument you have ever heard smuggles in its conclusion by choosing a time horizon. "Renting is throwing money away" assumes you stay forever. "Buying is a wealth trap" assumes you leave in three years. Strip away the slogans and the question that remains — the only version worth answering — is: for the number of years you will actually stay, which side costs less, all-in? This page builds both ledgers completely, runs one composite household through them, and shows the year the answer flips.

The buy ledger, all of it

Buying costs more than the mortgage payment. The full ledger: principal and interest; property taxes and homeowners insurance (budgeted here at 1.1% of value a year and $210 a month — your figures will differ by state and carrier, which is one reason homeowners insurance gets its own guide); maintenance, the cost new owners chronically under-budget and the maintenance reserve exists to fix; buying costs of roughly 2% of the price; selling costs of roughly 6% when you leave; and the opportunity cost of the down payment — cash parked in a wall instead of invested. Against those costs, buying returns two things: the principal you pay down, and any appreciation.

The rent ledger, all of it

Renting costs rent, renters insurance (the cheap, skip-it-at-your-peril policy in Renters Insurance, Explained), and expected rent increases — modeled here at 3% a year. What renting returns is the invested difference: the down payment and closing costs you did not spend, compounding instead. A rent ledger that omits the invested difference is as rigged as a buy ledger that omits maintenance.

One household, both ledgers

Composite household — invented figures, chosen to be ordinary: a $385,000 home or a comparable rental at $1,850 a month. The buyer puts 20% down ($77,000) plus 2% closing costs — $84,700 of cash in at the door — and borrows $308,000 at an illustrative 6.5% for 30 years (an example rate, not a quote; current survey context lives on this site's homepage card, dated weekly). Principal and interest: $1,947 a month. The renter invests the $84,700 at an assumed 5%. Home value and rent both grow 3% a year. One simplification, stated plainly because it favors buying: the renter does not invest the monthly cost difference.

If you leave afterTotal cost of buyingTotal cost of rentingWinner
3 yearsabout $88,100about $56,000Renting, by ~$32,000
5 yearsabout $123,300about $95,700Renting, by ~$27,600
7 yearsabout $155,900about $137,300Renting, by ~$18,500
10 yearsabout $199,100about $203,600Buying, by ~$4,500

Under these assumptions the break-even sits near year nine or ten — far past the "five-year rule" of folklore. Change the assumptions and the year moves: faster appreciation or cheaper money pulls it earlier; a pricier rental market relative to prices (the rent-vs.-price ratio is the single most powerful input) pushes it around most of all. What does not change is the shape: transaction costs and interest-heavy early payments make buying expensive early, and time is what repays them.

How to run your own version

Price the actual rental you would accept against the actual home you would buy — not a palace against a studio. Use your real tax and insurance figures, a maintenance line you believe, and your realistic expected tenure, including the probability that a job or family change shortens it (federal readers: relocation is a tenure risk with its own math). Then ask the question this page opened with. The household that should buy is the one staying long enough, in a market where buying is priced sanely against renting. The household that should rent is not throwing money away — it is buying flexibility at a price this ledger can compute. Either way, the down-payment cash has a job while you decide, and it belongs somewhere safer than a checking account — see Where the Emergency Fund Lives for the tiering logic. And once you do buy, the next question arrives immediately: extra principal, or invest the difference?

Official documentation and references

Keep going

Educational disclaimer: This article is general education, not personalized financial, tax, legal, or benefits advice. Primary sources, plan documents, and — for insurance and estate topics — your state's law and licensed professionals govern your situation. All numbers in examples are illustrative.