Borrowers shop for "a mortgage" as if it were one product. It is three decisions wearing one coat: the program (conventional, FHA, VA, USDA — who guarantees or insures the loan, and what that costs), the term (30, 20, or 15 years — how fast you repay), and the rate structure (fixed, or adjustable after an initial fixed period). Lenders blur the three because a confused borrower compares payments instead of costs. This page separates them.
Decision one: the program
| Program | Who it serves | Down payment shape | Insurance / fee shape |
|---|---|---|---|
| Conventional | Borrowers with solid credit and some cash | 3%+ for some first-time programs; 20% avoids PMI | PMI when under 20% down — and PMI ends as equity grows |
| FHA | Lower credit scores or thinner files | 3.5% with a 580+ score; 10% at 500–579 | 1.75% upfront premium plus annual MIP (0.55% for most 30-year loans) — usually for the life of the loan |
| VA | Eligible veterans, service members, some surviving spouses | Zero down is the design | One-time funding fee (2.15% first use, no down payment); no monthly insurance |
| USDA | Income-eligible buyers in eligible rural areas | Zero down | 1% upfront guarantee fee plus 0.35% annual fee, for the life of the loan |
The comparison that matters is not the sticker fee but the duration of the insurance. Conventional PMI is temporary — it falls away at 20% equity. FHA's annual premium on a minimum-down 30-year loan generally runs for the life of the loan, which is why FHA borrowers so often plan a refinance into conventional later (see Refinancing Your Mortgage). VA replaces monthly insurance with a one-time fee — and for a borrower with 20% down and strong credit, that fee can make VA the more expensive door, the comparison worked in VA Loans Explained. USDA's fees are the lightest of the four, gated by geography and a household income limit (115% of area median).
Decision two: the term
A 15-year loan is not a 30-year loan with twice the payment; it is a different cost structure — a lower rate, and interest charged on a balance that halves twice as fast. On any given balance, the 15-year typically costs a bit over half again the monthly payment of the 30-year and a small fraction of the total interest. The 20-year is the underused middle. The right question is not "which is cheapest" (the 15 always is) but "which payment survives a bad year" — the household cash-flow logic of Rent vs. Buy: The Full Math applies to the payment, too.
Decision three: fixed vs. adjustable
An ARM's name is its warning label: 7/6 ARM means the rate is fixed for seven years, then adjusts every six months. Three numbers govern what happens next, and all three belong in any ARM conversation. The index is the market rate the loan follows (today, typically a SOFR-based index) and the margin is the lender's fixed add-on; index plus margin is your future rate. The caps limit each adjustment and the lifetime maximum — a common structure caps the first adjustment at 2 points, later ones at 1, and the lifetime at 5 over the start rate. Run the worst case, not the starter case: on a $350,000 loan, a start rate of 5.5% is a payment of about $1,987; the lifetime cap of 10.5% is about $3,202. If the capped payment breaks the budget, the ARM's discount is rent you pay for risk you cannot carry. ARMs fit borrowers with a credible exit before the fixed period ends — a dated relocation, a planned sale — which is why federal households with PCS horizons are the classic case.
Comparing offers without being played
Decide program, term, and structure first; then request Loan Estimates from several lenders for the same loan on the same day, and compare the same three lines on each: the rate, the lender fees in Section A, and the total cash to close. Points and lender credits are just the rate wearing a costume — one point (1% of the loan) buys a rate reduction whose value depends entirely on how long you keep the loan, the same break-even logic as a refinance. And whatever you choose, the mortgage is one line of the housing ledger: whether extra principal beats investing is the follow-up decision.
Official documentation and references
- Consumer Financial Protection Bureau — Understand the different kinds of loans available / select the kind of loan that fits
- U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs — VA funding fee and loan closing costs (the chart behind the VA figures)
- Consumer Financial Protection Bureau — Mortgages hub (Loan Estimate shopping guidance)
Keep going
- Rent vs. Buy: The Full Math, Including the Years Renting Wins
- Refinancing Your Mortgage: Break-Even Math and the Reset Trap
- VA Loans Explained: Eligibility, Entitlement, and the Funding Fee
- Pay Extra on the Mortgage or the 401(k)?
Educational disclaimer: This article is general education, not personalized financial, tax, legal, or benefits advice. Primary sources, plan documents, and — for insurance and estate topics — your state's law and licensed professionals govern your situation. All numbers in examples are illustrative.