Sooner or later most federal households hold both account types at once — a TSP from the federal career and a 401(k) from a spouse’s job or a private-sector chapter. The plans look like siblings: same $25,500 elective deferral concept, same traditional/Roth choice, same age-55 and RMD architecture. Underneath, they differ in ways that change real decisions — what the accounts cost, what the employer puts in, what you can borrow, and what the money can own. This is the comparison, feature by feature, with the plan-specific fine print flagged where a 401(k)’s answer is “it depends on your employer’s document.”
The comparison
| Feature | TSP | Typical 401(k) |
|---|---|---|
| Fund costs | A few hundredths of a percent a year across the five core funds | Wide range — large employers rival the TSP; small plans can run 0.5%–1%+ all-in |
| Investment menu | Five index funds (G, F, C, S, I) + Lifecycle funds; a mutual fund window with extra fees and a 25%-of-balance cap | Employer-chosen menu, often 10–30 funds; sometimes a brokerage window; sometimes company stock |
| Employer money | Automatic 1% + match to 4% = 5% of pay, uniform government-wide | Plan-specific: common patterns match 3–6% of pay; some employers contribute nothing |
| The G Fund | Treasury yield with a principal that never declines — no equivalent exists in the private market | Stable value funds are the closest cousin, with insurer contracts and plan-specific terms |
| Loans | General purpose (1–5 yrs) and residential (1–15 yrs); you can keep repaying after separation | Plan-optional; most plans demand full repayment shortly after you leave the job, or the loan becomes a taxable distribution |
| In-service withdrawals | Restricted: hardship and age-59½ withdrawals under plan rules | Plan-specific; many plans are more permissive, some allow in-service rollovers |
| Withdrawal structure in retirement | Installments, partials, single distribution, or purchased annuity — uniform rules | Whatever the plan allows; some force lump sums at separation or restrict installments |
| Age-55 rule | Penalty-free distributions if you separate in/after the year you turn 55 | Same rule — it belongs to qualified plans generally, not to the TSP |
| Creditor protection | Strong federal protection | Strong ERISA protection; both beat IRAs in many states |
What the comparison means in practice
On cost, the TSP is the benchmark most 401(k)s are measured against — if a spouse’s plan charges 0.8% all-in, the household’s marginal savings dollar usually belongs in the TSP (after capturing both matches) or an IRA, not in the expensive plan beyond its match. On flexibility, the 401(k) often wins in-service and loses at separation: the loan-repayment trap in the table above has taxed more job-changers than any fee. On the G Fund, there is no contest — a retiree who wants a no-loss holding that still pays a real yield cannot replicate it outside the TSP, which is one reason the keep-versus-roll decision at separation (worked at Your TSP After You Leave) is not automatic even for committed IRA consolidators. The funds themselves are profiled at TSP Funds, Explained.
The two-account household playbook
Capture both matches first — a match is a 100% return that beats every fee argument. Then fill the cheaper plan’s space before the expensive one’s. Coordinate the tax treatment across both: if one spouse’s plan has a strong Roth option and the other’s does not, the household’s Roth dollars have a natural home. And when one of you changes jobs, decide the old 401(k)’s fate — leave, roll to the new plan, roll to the TSP (which accepts rollovers from eligible plans), or roll to an IRA — with the loan, fee, and age-55 consequences priced, not by default. The matching order across two employer plans is worked at Two 401(k)s: Which Match First.
The sentence to remember
The TSP is a superb low-cost core with a unique safe fund and rigid edges; a 401(k) is a lottery ticket whose value is printed in your spouse’s plan document. Compare the actual documents, not the account types in the abstract.
Official documentation and references
- Thrift Savings Plan — Individual funds and costs
- U.S. Department of Labor — Understanding Retirement Plan Fees and Expenses (401(k))
- Internal Revenue Service — 401(k) Plan Overview
Keep going
- TSP Funds, Explained: G, F, C, S, I and the Lifecycle Funds
- Your TSP After You Leave: The Keep-vs-Roll Decision
- Two 401(k)s: Which Match First
- Federal Employees hub — the whole system in order
Educational disclaimer: This article is general education, not personalized financial, tax, legal, or benefits advice. Primary sources, plan documents, and — for insurance and estate topics — your state's law and licensed professionals govern your situation. All numbers in examples are illustrative.