A federal household’s savings usually live in three tax environments at once: the TSP (taxed later, or never, for its Roth side), IRAs (same choice, different rules), and a taxable brokerage account (taxed as you go, flexible always). Generic advice treats the funding and withdrawal order as settled. For federal employees it mostly is — with two TSP-specific exceptions that can be worth thousands, and one coordination problem (the TSP’s RMD stands alone) that generic advice routinely gets wrong. This page lays out both sequences and flags exactly where the federal rules bend them.

Funding order while you work

The order is driven by matches and tax rates, not by account loyalty. First, TSP contributions to the full agency match — the 5% of pay is non-negotiable money. Second, an HSA if you are in a qualifying HDHP, for its triple tax treatment. Third, the household’s choice point: IRA contributions (Roth, for most mid-career households — the flexibility of withdrawing contributions and the absence of RMDs are worth real money) versus more TSP. The TSP’s costs are lower than almost any IRA’s fund lineup, but the IRA’s flexibility is broader; many households split the difference and do both. Fourth, the TSP to the $25,500 cap (plus catch-ups) — the remaining tax-deferred space is too valuable to leave unused at higher brackets. Fifth, taxable investing, which is not a failure state: no contribution limits, no RMDs, capital-gains rates, and a step-up in basis at death make the taxable account the most flexible leg, and the one that funds early-retirement years before penalty-free access opens elsewhere. The year-by-year dollar targets live at 2027 Contribution Limits.

Drawdown order in retirement

The conventional sequence — taxable first, tax-deferred second, Roth last — exists to let the tax-advantaged accounts compound longest. Federal retirees modify it in three places. The gap years are conversion years: between retirement and the start of Social Security and RMDs, brackets are often at their lifetime low, and converting traditional TSP/IRA money to Roth at 12% or 22% to fill a bracket is frequently the highest-value move available — the mechanics are at The Roth Conversion Ladder, and conversions run from an IRA more flexibly than from the TSP, which is one argument for a partial rollover at separation. The age-55 rule pins some money in the TSP: retire between 55 and 59½ and the TSP is your penalty-free source; the IRA is not, so the drawdown order in those years runs through the plan on purpose (see TSP Withdrawals and RMDs). Charitable givers route around the TSP: qualified charitable distributions come only from IRAs, so a charitably inclined retiree concentrates the IRA for QCDs after 70½ and draws spending from elsewhere.

The RMD coordination problem

Required minimum distributions do not aggregate across the TSP and IRAs. Your IRA RMD can be satisfied from any combination of your IRAs; your 403(b) RMD from your 403(b)s; but the TSP’s RMD must come out of the TSP, calculated on the TSP balance alone. Households that consolidate everything into an IRA at separation delete this problem; households that keep the TSP (for the G Fund, the age-55 rule, or creditor reasons) must run two RMD clocks forever. Neither answer is wrong — but “keep the TSP and forget it” is, because an unmanaged TSP RMD arrives on the plan’s schedule and lands in whatever bracket it lands in.

The coordination principle

While working, fund by tax value: match, HSA, flexible Roth space, then maximum deferral, then taxable. In retirement, draw by tax control: spend taxable, convert traditional at low brackets, keep Roth for last and for heirs — and let the two TSP exceptions (age 55, the standalone RMD) override the generic order whenever they apply to you.

Whichever accounts the coordination plan uses, the holdings inside them are usually the same few building blocks. Index Funds and ETFs covers what they are, what they cost, and the three-fund assembly this site’s allocation guidance assumes.

The taxable account in this coordination plan deserves its own treatment: it has no contribution limit, no required distributions, and an annual tax bill the other two accounts defer or avoid. Taxable Brokerage Accounts and Asset Location covers what it is for — and which assets belong in it instead of the sheltered accounts.

Coordinating three accounts only works if the combined portfolio is periodically restored to its intended mix — drift in one account is drift in the plan. Rebalancing Your Portfolio covers the calendar, threshold, and cash-flow methods, and why the tax-advantaged accounts are where the trades should happen.

Official documentation and references

Keep going

Educational disclaimer: This article is general education, not personalized financial, tax, legal, or benefits advice. Primary sources, plan documents, and — for insurance and estate topics — your state's law and licensed professionals govern your situation. All numbers in examples are illustrative.