Nobody's portfolio stays the allocation they picked. Markets move the pieces at different speeds, and the portfolio quietly becomes a different portfolio — usually a riskier one, because the asset that drifts upward is usually stocks after a good run. Rebalancing is the maintenance that restores the chosen mix: selling a little of what grew heavy, buying what fell light. It is not market timing and it does not promise higher returns. It promises that the risk you are running is the risk you decided to run, which is the promise the whole allocation decision in Asset Allocation by Age and Risk rests on.
The drift, in numbers
Start with $500,000 at 60/40: $300,000 in stocks, $200,000 in bonds. Stocks rise 30% over a strong stretch while bonds rise 2%. The account now holds $390,000 of stocks and $204,000 of bonds — $594,000 total, split 65.7 / 34.3. Nobody chose that mix; the market chose it. Restoring 60/40 means moving $33,600 from stocks to bonds. Left alone through another cycle, the drift compounds: the portfolio enters the next crash carrying more stock risk than its owner signed for, and — the mirror image — enters recoveries light on the asset that fell, having never bought the dip that rebalancing buys automatically.
Three triggers: calendar, threshold, cash flow
Calendar rebalancing picks a date — annually is plenty for most households — and resets the mix regardless of how far it drifted. Simple, memorable, and occasionally trades when nothing much moved. Threshold rebalancing trades only when a holding leaves its band; the classic tolerance is the 5/25 rule: rebalance when an allocation is off by 5 percentage points absolutely, or by 25% of its own size relatively (a 10% holding gets attention at 7.5% or 12.5%). Thresholds trade less and respond to real drift, at the cost of having to look. Cash-flow rebalancing never sells anything: new contributions go to whatever is light, and withdrawals come from whatever is heavy. For savers still adding money it is often sufficient by itself, and it is the only method with zero tax and zero transaction friction. Most households end up combining all three — cash flows first, an annual look, thresholds as the tripwire between looks.
Doing it without donating the benefit to taxes
Order matters. Rebalance inside tax-advantaged accounts first, where sales have no tax consequence — inside an IRA freely, and inside the TSP by interfund transfer, which federal rules currently limit to two unrestricted transfers per calendar month, with further transfers that month allowed only into the G Fund (5 CFR § 1601.34) — rarely a binding constraint on an annual chore. In a taxable account, prefer cash-flow rebalancing and, when a sale is unavoidable, pair it with the loss-harvesting discipline of Tax-Loss Harvesting rather than realizing gains to fix a two-point drift. Rebalance across the whole household, not account by account: the mix that matters is the combined one, arranged per Asset Location, and a household can often restore it by adjusting a single account's holdings. Finally, keep the chore boring on purpose. The investors rebalancing serves best are the ones who treat it like changing the HVAC filter — scheduled, mechanical, and emotionally uneventful — because the entire point is to make the disciplined trade (trim the winner, add to the laggard) at exactly the moments when instinct argues loudest against it.
Official documentation and references
- 5 CFR Part 1601 — Participants' Choices of TSP Investment Funds (§ 1601.34 states the interfund-transfer limits)
- FINRA Investor Insights — portfolio maintenance and diversification explainers
- Investor.gov (SEC) — Asset Allocation (the mix rebalancing exists to maintain)
Keep going
- Asset Allocation by Age and Risk: Choosing Your Stock-Bond Mix
- Index Funds and ETFs: Building a Low-Cost Portfolio
- Taxable Brokerage Accounts and Asset Location: The Third Bucket
- Tax-Loss Harvesting, Explained: Turning Losses Into a Tax Asset
Educational disclaimer: This article is general education, not personalized financial, tax, legal, or benefits advice. Primary sources, plan documents, and — for insurance and estate topics — your state's law and licensed professionals govern your situation. All numbers in examples are illustrative.