Leaving federal service triggers a TSP decision that most leavers make by default — usually by doing nothing, or by rolling everything to an IRA because a brochure suggested it. Both can be right; neither should be automatic. The TSP is an unusual account: the cheapest large plan in the country, home to one fund that exists nowhere else, and governed by withdrawal rules that differ from an IRA's in ways that matter most to exactly the people most likely to leave early — separators in their 50s, and anyone with an outstanding TSP loan.
Our earlier guide covered the mechanics of the three options at separation. This one is the decision layer on top: what you gain and permanently give up with each door, the traps that catch leavers in the first 90 days, and the order in which to decide. If you are mid-separation, run the money side first with the Separation Runway Calculator — the TSP choice is easier once you know how much cash the transition itself requires.
The case for leaving it exactly where it is
The TSP's expense ratios — a few hundredths of a percent — are matched by institutional index funds but beaten almost nowhere, and simplicity is a feature: five funds, no sales layer, no one calling you. The distinctive asset is the G Fund: it pays a long-term Treasury yield with a government-guaranteed stable principal — a return/risk combination no IRA product replicates, and the closest thing in any portfolio to a free lunch for the bond portion of a retiree's allocation. Money rolled out of the TSP cannot be rolled back in once you are separated (unless you return to federal service), so the G Fund door closes one way.
Staying also preserves two structural advantages. The age-55 rule: separate from federal service in or after the year you turn 55, and TSP withdrawals are penalty-free — while money rolled to an IRA is locked until 59½ (absent a 72(t) schedule). And federal accounts carry strong creditor protection without depending on state law. For a 56-year-old separator, those two facts alone can settle the question.
The case for rolling to an IRA — and its two traps
The honest advantages of an IRA: vastly wider investment choice, Roth conversion mechanics that are simpler and more flexible than in-plan options, consolidation with other accounts, and estate-handling conveniences some custodians do better. If your plan is a decade of gap-year Roth conversions, an IRA is the more comfortable workshop.
Trap one: the backdoor Roth collision. Rolling pre-tax TSP money into a Traditional IRA makes future backdoor Roth contributions taxable under the pro-rata rule — the rollover that looks like housekeeping can quietly tax a strategy for years. Trap two: the outstanding loan. If you separate with a TSP loan in repayment, you have a limited window (90 days under current TSP rules) to repay it in full; after that the balance is treated as a taxable distribution — and if you are under 59½ without the age-55 protection applying, a penalty can follow. The loan decision belongs in your separation checklist before your last day, not after the letter arrives. Our separation checklist sequences it.
Withdrawals: the modern rules, and why partial is usually right
Since the TSP Modernization Act, separated participants are no longer forced into all-or-nothing choices: you can take partial distributions, change installment payments, and mix withdrawals with a remaining balance that keeps growing — flexibility the old rules denied, and a reason old advice about the TSP (“you have to leave to get control”) is obsolete. You can also leave the account untouched for years; there is no deadline to decide at separation, and required minimum distributions follow the same ages as other plans.
The withdrawal mistakes to avoid are tax-shaped, not investment-shaped: a lump sum in a high-income year (a final paycheck, a leave payout, and a distribution stacked together can vault you two brackets), a rollover check made out to you personally (mandatory 20% withholding and a 60-day clock — always move money trustee-to-trustee), and withdrawing before confirming whether the age-55 rule covers you. Every one of these is avoidable with a calendar and one phone call to the TSP before the form, not after.
The decision, in order
1. Any TSP loan? Resolve its repayment before separation; this deadline outranks every other consideration. 2. Separating at 55 or later? Strong presumption to keep at least the money you may spend before 59½ inside the TSP. 3. Do you value the G Fund as your safe asset? If it anchors your allocation, keep enough in the TSP to hold it. 4. Backdoor Roth in your future? Keep pre-tax money out of Traditional IRAs — which means the TSP stays, or rolls to a new employer's 401(k), not to an IRA. 5. Otherwise — consolidation, conversions, and investment choice are legitimate reasons to roll some or all, trustee-to-trustee, in a low-income year when the tax side is calm.
Notice the pattern: the TSP decision is mostly about options that expire. Decide the expiring ones first, and the rest of the choice is preference, which you can revisit — the account will wait. What it will not do is warn you; the TSP sends statements, not advice. That part is yours, and now it is sequenced.
Separates at 56 with $410,000 in the TSP, $18,000 loan outstanding, plans to spend ~$30,000/yr from the account until Social Security at 67.
Roll everything to an IRA: withdrawals before 59½ face the 10% early penalty — ≈ $3,000/yr of avoidable cost — and the loan, if unpaid in 90 days, becomes a taxable distribution.Keep it in the TSP: age-55 rule makes withdrawals penalty-free; repay the $18,000 loan from the leave payout inside the window; hold the spending reserve in the G Fund.Same account, same balance — the wrapper choice alone is worth roughly $10,000+ across the 3½ years to 59½.Official documentation and references
- TSP.gov — official site (account access, fund and withdrawal information)
- TSP.gov — Living in retirement (withdrawals, installments and RMDs)
- IRS — Required Minimum Distributions (ages and rules that also govern the TSP)
Keep going
- Your TSP When You Leave Federal Service: Keep It, Roll It, or Withdraw It
- Leaving Federal Service: The Separation Money Checklist
- Roth Conversions in the Gap Years: Use the Cheapest Tax Years of Your Life
Educational disclaimer: This article is general education, not personalized financial, tax, legal, or benefits advice. Primary sources, plan documents, and — for insurance and estate topics — your state's law and licensed professionals govern your situation. All numbers in examples are illustrative.