There is a stretch of years in many retirements when taxable income falls off a cliff: the paycheck has stopped, Social Security has not started (or has been deliberately delayed), and required minimum distributions are still years away. In those “gap years,” a household that spent decades in the 22–24% brackets can find itself in the 10–12% brackets — or even owing no tax at all. Every dollar of Traditional retirement money converted to Roth during that window is taxed at the gap-year rate instead of the rate it will face later, when Social Security and forced distributions stack on top of each other.
This is the practical sequel to our Roth vs Traditional guide: that decision was about contributions. This one is about the second chance — converting money that is already Traditional, in the years when conversion is cheapest, with the two traps (Medicare premiums and bracket creep) managed deliberately.
Why the window exists — and when it closes
Three clocks create the window. Social Security can be delayed to 70, and our claiming guide explains why delaying is often right on insurance grounds alone. RMDs from Traditional accounts now begin at 73 for most current retirees (75 for younger cohorts) under SECURE 2.0. And wages, for early retirees, are zero. A household retiring at 62 can have the better part of a decade in which the only taxable income is what it chooses to create — interest, dividends, and conversions themselves.
The window closes from both ends. Once Social Security starts, up to 85% of benefits become taxable and fill the lower brackets. Once RMDs start, the IRS chooses a minimum conversion-sized distribution for you every year, at whatever bracket results. Conversions done before both clocks start are the ones done at rates you select.
Sizing a conversion: fill the bracket, don't blow through it
The standard technique is bracket-filling: each December, estimate the year's taxable income, then convert exactly enough to reach the top of your target bracket — commonly the top of the 12% bracket, or the top of 22% for households whose future RMDs will clearly land higher. Converting beyond the target bracket pays a higher rate today to avoid a lower rate tomorrow, which is the original mistake running in reverse.
Two refinements separate a plan from a guess. First, project the alternative: estimate your future RMD at 73 (balance growing at a conservative rate, divided by the IRS life-expectancy factor) and the bracket it creates stacked on Social Security. If that future bracket is 12% anyway, conversions at 12% buy little; if it is 22–24%, conversions at 12% are buying a permanent 10-point spread. Second, remember state taxes: converting after a move from a high-tax state to a no-tax state adds the state spread to the win; converting the year before such a move wastes it.
The IRMAA trap, and the other costs nobody mentions
Medicare premiums are means-tested on a two-year lag: the income on your tax return at 63 sets your Part B and Part D premiums at 65. A large conversion can push you over an IRMAA threshold — and the thresholds are cliffs, not brackets, so exceeding one by a dollar raises premiums on the entire year, for both spouses. For households aged 63+, the conversion target is often not the top of a tax bracket but the floor of the next IRMAA tier, whichever is lower. Medicare publishes the current tiers and surcharges; check them every year, because the plan that was safe at 61 can be expensive at 64.
Other real costs: conversion income can reduce ACA premium credits for pre-65 retirees buying marketplace coverage (sometimes making small conversions far more expensive than the tax table suggests), can push capital gains out of the 0% rate zone, and is irrevocable — recharacterization of conversions has not been allowed since 2018. The tax is also due in cash: pay it from taxable savings, not from the converted amount, or you shrink the very shelter you are building and may owe an early-withdrawal penalty on the withheld portion if you are under 59½.
A sane multi-year pattern
Treat the gap years as a project with an annual December routine: project the year's income, check the IRMAA tier boundary for your age, convert up to the lower of your bracket target or the IRMAA floor, pay the tax from taxable cash, and record the running total converted against the plan. Spread over six to ten years, even a modest $30,000–$50,000 a year moves $200,000–$400,000 from the forced-distribution pile to the never-taxed-again pile — and every converted dollar also lowers future RMDs, which lowers the future bracket, which is the whole game.
Coordinate with the rest of the system: conversions pair naturally with delayed Social Security, with harvesting the 0% capital-gains zone in the lowest years (not the same year as a big conversion — they compete for the same bracket space), and with the catch-up funding order in your final working years. And keep perspective on scale: this is optimization at the margin of a plan that still has to be funded. A household behind on savings gains more from the catch-up order than from any conversion calendar.
Couple, both 64, retired, no wages. Taxable income before conversion: $18,000 (interest, dividends, small pension). Standard deduction (MFJ, both 65+ soon) leaves large 12%-bracket headroom.
Convert $60,000: taxable income rises to ≈$78,000 — still inside the 12% marginal bracket. Federal tax on the conversion ≈ $6,600 (blended ~11%).Same $60,000 as a forced RMD at 75, stacked on Social Security in the 22% bracket: ≈ $13,200.Spread kept: ≈ $6,600 per $60,000 converted — repeated annually across the window. Watch the IRMAA tier boundary at their ages before sizing year two.Official documentation and references
- IRS — Required Minimum Distributions (when forced distributions start)
- IRS — Traditional and Roth IRAs (conversion taxation basics)
- Medicare.gov — Medicare costs and income-related premium adjustments (IRMAA)
Keep going
- Roth vs Traditional: The Bracket That Matters Is the One You'll Retire In
- Claiming Social Security Late Is Longevity Insurance — Price It That Way
- 2026 Contribution Limits: TSP, 401(k), IRA, and HSA
Educational disclaimer: This article is general education, not personalized financial, tax, legal, or benefits advice. Primary sources, plan documents, and — for insurance and estate topics — your state's law and licensed professionals govern your situation. All numbers in examples are illustrative.