Tool · Estate Planning

Beneficiary Audit

How to use this audit

Answer from the actual forms, not from memory. For each account, open the custodian's or plan's beneficiary page (or your last confirmation statement) and check: who is primary, who is contingent, whether the shares total 100%, and when you last reviewed it. If you cannot see a designation, that is itself a finding — select “Not sure” and the fix list will tell you what to confirm. Untick “I have this account” for account types you do not own.

Methodology — how the score works

Each included account starts at 100. Points are deducted for the failure modes estate practitioners report most, weighted by consequence: no primary beneficiary −40; a former spouse possibly still named −35; a minor named directly −25; shares not totaling 100% −20; no contingent beneficiary −15; not reviewed since the last life event −15; “not sure” answers −10 to −20. Three findings force an At Risk status regardless of score: no primary beneficiary, a former spouse possibly named, or a minor named directly. Status bands: 90–100 OK, 60–89 Review, under 60 At Risk. The overall score is the mean of included accounts.

Why these checks — the short version

Designations override wills because they are contract instructions to the custodian. For ERISA employer plans, the Supreme Court has twice required plans to pay the person on the form: Egelhoff v. Egelhoff (2001), where a state law automatically revoking an ex-spouse's designation was preempted, and Kennedy v. Plan Administrator for DuPont (2009), where an ex-spouse who had waived her interest in the divorce decree still collected, because the form was never changed. Minors named directly typically trigger court-supervised conservatorship. Missing contingents and percentages that do not total 100% hand the decision to custodian defaults. Our guide Beneficiary Designations Beat Your Will explains each failure mode in full.

Limitations

  • This audit checks designation hygiene — completeness, currency, and internal consistency. It cannot judge whether the people you named are the right choices for your family or your taxes.
  • State law varies: revocation-on-divorce statutes, TOD availability, and community-property rules differ by state. Where state law matters, the fix list says to check yours.
  • Retirement-account designations carry tax consequences under the SECURE Act's 10-year rule for most non-spouse beneficiaries. Changing a designation is free; changing it well may deserve advice.
  • This tool is general education, not legal advice, and it does not create or file any document.

Official documentation and references

Educational disclaimer: This tool provides general educational checks, not legal or personalized financial advice.