The comparison most federal employees run is salary against salary, and it is rigged: your federal salary is only part of what a year of federal service buys. Each additional year purchases roughly another 1% of your high-3 as a lifetime annuity, moves you toward (or deeper into) eligibility thresholds, protects the right to carry FEHB into retirement with the government still paying the larger share of premiums, and comes with a 5%-of-pay TSP contribution from your agency. A private offer has to beat all of that, not just the number on your SF-50. This page prices each piece so the two offers can be compared on one line.

Value a year of federal service

ComponentWhat a year buys (illustrative, $110,000 salary, $105,000 high-3)Annual value
Annuity accrual+1% of high-3, for life, from retirement$1,050/yr of retirement income — a stream worth roughly $20,000+ in lump-sum terms at retirement
Supplement eligibilityEach year adds 1/40 to the supplement fraction and moves you toward the 30-year / 20-year gatesVaries; the supplement itself is worked in the estimator
TSP agency moneyAutomatic 1% + up to 4% matchUp to $5,500/yr at this salary
FEHB employer share (working)Government pays roughly 70–75% of premiumsCommonly $10,000–$20,000/yr of premium value
FEHB into retirementThe same employer share continues after retirement if you meet the five-year rule — and is lost entirely on a deferred retirementThe largest single number in many comparisons

The FEHB row deserves emphasis, because it is the one private offers almost never match. Retiree health coverage with an employer subsidy, available from your retirement date rather than at 65, is the benefit that private-sector early retirees spend five figures a year replacing — or go without. Leaving federal service before you can retire on an immediate annuity does not defer this benefit; it deletes it. The full mechanics are at FEHB After You Leave: TCC Math and the 5-Year Rule.

Now price the private offer the same way

Take the offer’s salary, then subtract what the federal column provided: the employer’s retirement contribution (a 401(k) match of 4–6% is typical; your federal accrual plus match was worth materially more), the health premium share you will now pay, and the price of replacing FEHB-in-retirement later — either by planning to work to 65, buying coverage in the gap years, or treating the lost subsidy as a lump sum the higher salary must repay over your remaining career. Then adjust for what the offer genuinely adds: faster salary growth, bonus or equity the federal system cannot pay, remote flexibility, or escape from a plateaued grade. None of those are imaginary; they are simply worth less than the headline gap suggests until the federal package is priced in full.

The two situations where leaving clearly wins, and the one where it clearly does not

Leaving tends to win early, when the annuity accrual forgone is small and decades of higher private salary compound in a 401(k) — and when a genuinely large salary jump (40%+, not 10%) is on the table. It tends to lose late, within sight of an immediate retirement: the final federal years are the most valuable of the career because they stack annuity percentage, high-3 growth, supplement eligibility, and the FEHB bridge all at once. The middle case — mid-career, modest raise — is where people most often leave money behind by comparing salaries. If you do leave, the departure checklist matters more than the negotiation: The Federal Separation Checklist and Your TSP When You Leave cover the moves that cannot be undone, and the deferred-annuity math is in the FERS Annuity Estimator.

The one-line test

Ask the offer this question: does the extra salary, saved and invested over your remaining working years, buy back the annuity stream, the supplement, and the retiree health subsidy you are giving up? If the spreadsheet cannot say yes with room to spare, the raise is a pay cut wearing a bigger number.

A transfer inside the government raises a cousin of this page’s question: not whether to leave, but whether the move pays after the house, the spouse’s income reset, and the taxes are counted. Relocating for a Federal Job works that ledger, including the allowances the Federal Travel Regulation actually authorizes.

This page prices the federal side of the comparison; the worksheet that prices any two offers against each other — including the speculative bucket that counts equity and prestige at zero — is Total-Compensation Analysis: How to Price a Job Offer Whole.

Career and compensation: the rest of this cluster — Total-Compensation Analysis for pricing an offer whole, Negotiating Salary and Promotions, Starting a Side Income, the outside-work rules for federal employees, and planning when one spouse is federal.

Official documentation and references

Keep going

Educational disclaimer: This article is general education, not personalized financial, tax, legal, or benefits advice. Primary sources, plan documents, and — for insurance and estate topics — your state's law and licensed professionals govern your situation. All numbers in examples are illustrative.