Two offers land in the same week. One pays $118,000; the other pays $108,000 and "has great benefits." Most candidates compare the two salaries and treat the benefits as weather — pleasant or unpleasant, but unpriced. Benefits are not weather. They are dollars with rules, and this page prices them the way the audit in Audit the Benefits You Sleepwalked Into prices the ones you already have: line by line, at the value they will actually deliver to your household, separated into cash, deferred, insurance, and speculation.
The worksheet: four buckets, in order of certainty
Cash compensation — salary, plus bonus or commission counted at its reliable level: the target figure discounted by how the plan actually pays (ask what the team averaged last year, not what the plan maximum is). Deferred compensation — the employer's retirement contributions, valued in full because they are contractual: the match formula applied to your salary, any automatic contribution, and profit-sharing at its recent average. Which match to capture first across two jobs is its own problem, solved in Two 401(k)s: Which Match First? Insurance value — the employer's share of health premiums, employer HSA or FSA contributions, and the disability and life coverage the employer funds, valued at what replacing them yourself would cost. Time — paid days off you will actually use, priced at your daily rate; an unusable PTO bank is worth zero and should be counted as such. Everything else — equity, options, RSUs at a private company, "exposure," the prestige of the logo — goes in a fifth bucket labeled speculative, listed on the worksheet and added at zero.
The composite comparison
Invented offers, ordinary numbers. Offer A: $118,000 salary, 3% match, employer pays $6,900 a year toward health premiums. Offer B: $108,000 salary, 6% match, employer pays $8,500 toward premiums plus a $1,500 HSA contribution.
| Line (year one) | Offer A | Offer B |
|---|---|---|
| Salary | $118,000 | $108,000 |
| Employer retirement contribution | $3,540 (3%) | $6,480 (6%) |
| Employer-paid health premium | $6,900 | $8,500 |
| Employer HSA contribution | $0 | $1,500 |
| Countable total | $128,440 | $124,480 |
B's richer benefits close $6,040 of the $10,000 salary gap — and do not close it. A still leads by $3,960 in year one. B's two extra PTO days (about $830 at B's daily rate) narrow it to roughly $3,130, and if B's health plan also spares the household a working-spouse surcharge or a worse deductible, the remaining gap can vanish — which is precisely why the worksheet exists: the answer is in the lines, not in the adjective "great." Run the comparison over three years as well as one, because vesting cliffs, raise bases (a 3% raise on $118,000 is $360 more than on $108,000, every year, compounding), and one-time sign-on payments distort year one in both directions.
The costs of switching, counted once
Changing jobs has its own ledger: the bonus or raise cycle you walk away from, unvested balances left behind, a possible gap in health coverage priced through the split-or-join analysis if a spouse's plan bridges it, new commute or remote-work costs, and the reset of every deductible in January. Count these as year-one deductions from the new offer, not as vibes. Then negotiate — with the worksheet as your evidence, in the order Negotiating Salary and Promotions lays out. Federal readers weighing a move in the other direction have the mirror-image version of this worksheet in Staying Federal vs. Leaving, and the tool that prices the health-plan half of any offer is the Benefits Optimizer.
Official documentation and references
- U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics — earnings data by occupation (context for pricing an offer; population data, not a benchmark for a specific employer)
- Internal Revenue Service — Tax Withholding Estimator (what a salary change does to take-home pay)
- Consumer Financial Protection Bureau — Consumer tools (household cash-flow framework)
Keep going
- Negotiating Salary and Promotions: Price the Role, Then Ask
- Audit the Benefits You Sleepwalked Into
- Two 401(k)s: Which Match First?
- Benefits Optimizer — price the health-plan half of the offer
Educational disclaimer: This article is general education, not personalized financial, tax, legal, or benefits advice. Primary sources, plan documents, and — for insurance and estate topics — your state's law and licensed professionals govern your situation. All numbers in examples are illustrative.