Tool · Government & Military

FERS Refund or Deferred Annuity?

When you leave federal service, your own FERS retirement deductions sit in the Civil Service Retirement and Disability Fund as your “lump-sum credit.” You can take them back now as a refund — which voids the annuity that service earned — or leave them and claim a deferred annuity later. The catch is the asymmetry: if you were hired before 2013 you paid in 0.8% of pay; if you were hired in 2014 or later you paid 4.4% — for the identical annuity. Enter your numbers and see both sides priced in age-62 dollars.

FreeNo sign-upRuns 100% in your browserEvery step of the math shown

Your federal service

When were you first covered by FERS? Your hire era set the percentage of every paycheck that went into the fund — and the annuity formula does not care which era you are in. If you are unsure, your SF-50’s retirement plan code settles it. (Special-category employees — law enforcement, firefighters, air traffic controllers — paid an extra 0.5 percentage point; this tool prices regular FERS.)

The estimate multiplies your era rate by your high-3 salary for every year — but your real deductions were taken from each year’s actual pay, which was usually lower than your career-peak high-3. If your pay rose over your career, the estimate overstates your refund. If OPM or your final pay records give you the real lump-sum credit, enter it here and it replaces the estimate.

The comparison’s assumptions

One return is used for both sides — it grows the refund to age 62 and discounts the annuity’s payments back to age 62. That makes the verdict a statement about the annuity’s built-in return versus your assumption, and close cases flip when the assumption moves. For scale: Social Security’s actuaries put life expectancy at 62 at about 20 more years for men and 23 for women, so the default plan-to age of 85 is a reasonable, slightly longevity-generous yardstick.

Read this before you file anything: what the math leaves out

  • A deferred annuity cannot bring back FEHB, FEGLI, or FEDVIP. OPM is blunt: a deferred annuitant is not eligible to re-enroll in health benefits, life insurance, or dental and vision coverage in retirement. To be precise about cause: the refund does not cause that loss — leaving federal service did. But do not let the two decisions blur together.
  • Separated at or after your MRA with 10+ years of service? Stop. You may hold a postponed (MRA+10) annuity, not a deferred one — and postponed annuitants can reinstate FEHB and FEGLI when the annuity begins, if they had five years of coverage before separating. For you, a refund puts retiree health coverage on the table too. Check with OPM before doing anything.
  • There is no FERS annuity supplement on a deferred annuity. The supplement is only for immediate, unreduced retirements before 62.
  • Taking the refund is permanent; leaving the money is not. A refund voids all annuity rights from that service. Leaving the contributions in place keeps both doors open — you can generally still apply for the refund later, any time before the annuity starts.
  • The way back is a redeposit — refund plus interest. If you return to federal service, you can buy the service back, but only by repaying the full refund plus interest (the same variable rate, 4.25% for 2026, compounding annually), and the redeposit must be finished before OPM finalizes your eventual retirement claim. Skip it, and the service still counts toward eligibility and your high-3 — but not toward the size of the annuity. Our redeposit guide prices that path.
  • Dying before 62 changes the deferred side completely. If you die before the annuity begins, a monthly survivor annuity exists only if you had 10+ years of service and were married at separation (your spouse gets 50% of the earned annuity, generally starting when you would have reached the unreduced date). Otherwise your survivors receive only the lump-sum credit — roughly what the refund would have paid. The refund path, invested, is simply inherited in full.
  • Your high-3 is frozen, and no COLA accrues while you wait. The annuity is computed on your salary at separation, in nominal dollars, for the entire deferral — at 3% inflation, 22 years of waiting cuts its purchasing power roughly in half before the first check. After 62, the FERS “diet COLA” applies (full CPI up to 2%, 2% between 2–3%, CPI minus 1 above 3%).
  • Your TSP is not part of this decision. The agency automatic and matching contributions are already yours in your TSP account either way. A refund touches only your FERS deductions — and it also voids credit for any military service deposit folded into the lump-sum credit.
  • If you are married, the annuity shrinks at claim time. The figures here are the unreduced annuity. At commencement, a married annuitant’s annuity is automatically computed with the maximum survivor benefit — a 10% reduction — unless a spouse gives notarized consent to less.

How to read the result

Both sides are priced at age 62. The refund is grown forward at your assumed return; the annuity is valued as the present value, at 62, of its yearly payments from 62 to your plan-to age, discounted at the same return. The payback line divides the grown refund by the annual annuity: it is the number of years of checks that replace the entire invested refund — after that age, every check is money the refund path would have had to earn by itself. That is the annuity’s character in one number: it is longevity insurance, not an investment account.

Methodology: the formula, in the open

The refund is your own deductions: your hire-era rate (0.8%, 3.1%, or 4.4% of basic pay, per 5 U.S.C. § 8422) times pay times years — estimated here on your high-3, or taken from your override entry. The deferred annuity is 1% × high-3 × years of creditable service under 5 U.S.C. § 8415, claimable at 62 with five years of civilian service, earlier at a reduction with ten. The early-start reduction is 5/12 of 1% per full month under 62 (§ 8415(h)), waived for 30+ years of service, or 20+ years when payments start at 60 or later.

Assumptions and limitations

  • The refund is modeled contributions-only. By statute (5 U.S.C. § 8401(19)), OPM adds interest to the lump-sum credit when the service aggregates more than one year, at the Civil Service Retirement and Disability Fund’s variable yield — 4.25% for calendar year 2026. The exact amount depends on when each paycheck deduction landed, so it cannot be reconstructed here. The real refund is somewhat larger than modeled, which makes this tool conservative against the refund.
  • The contribution estimate likely overstates. Real deductions were the era rate on each year’s actual basic pay; using the career-peak high-3 for every year inflates the total for anyone whose pay rose. The override field exists for your real figure. The two refund-side simplifications pull in opposite directions.
  • The annuity is computed at 1.0% — always. The 1.1% factor in § 8415(i) is granted only to an employee who retires under § 8412 (an immediate retirement) at 62 or older with 20+ years, at the time of separation. A deferred annuitant retires under § 8413 and separated before 62, so 1.1% is legally unavailable — no matter how many years of service or how long payments are delayed. Many explainers get this wrong.
  • The annuity’s value ignores its post-62 diet COLAs, which understates the annuity side; taxes are ignored on both sides (refund basis comes back tax-free and only its interest is taxable; the annuity is taxed as ordinary income as paid, with a small tax-free slice under the IRS Simplified Method).
  • One assumed return does both jobs — growing the refund and discounting the annuity. Near the margin, a single percentage point flips the verdict; treat a close result as “the non-math factors decide,” not as a precise answer.
  • The annuity shown is the unreduced amount, before any survivor-election reduction (10% for the full survivor benefit) and before taxes. Unused sick leave is not creditable toward a deferred annuity.
  • This tool is educational and is not personalized financial, tax, or benefits advice. Nothing you enter leaves your browser. OPM’s figures — from your SF-50, your final agency records, and OPM itself — govern your actual case.

Where the decision goes next

If the refund wins on your numbers, the mechanics matter as much as the decision: the step-by-step refund guide covers SF 3106, the 31-day wait, the 20% withholding trap, and the 60-day rollover window. If you are still deciding, what your FERS pension is worth if you leave early walks the deferred annuity itself, and the Federal Separation Runway Calculator prices the rest of your separation — leave payout, severance, and savings — on the same page of clocks.

Official documentation and references

Educational disclaimer: General educational estimates only, not personalized financial, tax, or benefits advice.