Ask a room of federal employees what happens to their pension if they quit at 45, and most will say it disappears. It does not — provided you leave your contributions in the retirement system. What you have is a deferred annuity: a pension calculated from your service and your high-3 salary, frozen in time, that you can claim at a later age. The catch is in the details — when it can start, what reductions apply, and what you permanently lose (hint: health coverage) by taking the deferred path.

The other path — taking a refund of your contributions — is the one OPM warns about in unusually blunt language. This guide works through both, with the formula, so you can see what your years of service are actually worth before you trade them for a check.

Deferred retirement: who qualifies and when it pays

Under OPM's FERS rules, a separated employee who leaves their contributions in the system can claim a deferred annuity at these points: age 62 with at least 5 years of creditable civilian service; age 60 with 20 years; at their minimum retirement age (MRA, between 55 and 57 depending on birth year) with 30 years — all unreduced — or from their MRA with 10 to 29 years, reduced by 5% for each year the annuity starts before age 62. The annuity uses the standard FERS formula: 1% of your high-3 average salary for each year of service, or 1.1% per year if you are 62 or older with at least 20 years when it begins. Your high-3 is frozen at separation — it is not inflation-adjusted while you wait — which is the quiet cost of deferring for a long time.

Two losses surprise people. First, a deferred annuity carries no FEHB: you cannot reenroll in federal health benefits when the deferred annuity starts, at any age. (Postponed retirement under MRA+10 is a different status — employees who separate at or after their MRA with 10+ years and postpone their annuity can reenroll in FEHB when it begins, if they met the 5-year coverage rule. Deferred retirees cannot.) Second, unused sick leave is not creditable at all toward a deferred annuity — neither for eligibility nor for the computation — while for an immediate annuity it adds to the service used in the formula. Both facts belong in the decision, and neither appears on the refund form.

The refund: what you get and what it voids

If you separate before being eligible for an immediate annuity, you may apply (on form SF 3106, after at least 31 days of separation) for a refund of the FERS contributions deducted from your pay. The government keeps its share; you receive only your own deductions, with interest only in limited circumstances. OPM's warning deserves quoting in substance: receiving a refund voids all annuity rights based on that service. The years do not become “paused.” They become gone.

There is one road back: if you are later reemployed in a FERS-covered position, you may redeposit the refunded amount plus interest and restore the service credit. If you do not redeposit, the refunded service generally cannot be counted in computing an annuity (for service covered after October 28, 2009, it may still count toward meeting an eligibility threshold and toward your high-3, but not toward the benefit amount). For an employee certain they will never return to federal service, with very few years in, the refund can be rational — the deferred annuity from three years of service is small. For anyone with a decade or more, the math in the example below usually settles the question.

MRA+10 and the middle path

Employees who separate at or after their MRA with at least 10 years have a third option beyond immediate-or-deferred: take an immediate annuity with the 5%-per-year-under-62 reduction, or postpone the start to shrink or erase the reduction — with 20 or more years, postponing to age 60 eliminates it entirely. Postponing also preserves the ability to reenroll in FEHB when the annuity starts (subject to the 5-year rule), which for many households is worth more than the annuity difference itself, because it bridges the pre-Medicare years with federal health coverage at the government-subsidized share.

The decision framework is therefore three questions, in order. How many years do I have, and what is the deferred annuity worth at each start age? Am I in the MRA+10 window, where postponement protects FEHB? And is there any realistic chance I return to federal service, which changes both the refund and redeposit analysis?

A worked example (illustrative numbers)

An employee leaves at 48 with 14 years of service and a high-3 of $98,000. Their own FERS contributions over those years total roughly $11,000 (the standard employee rate for most of the period).

ChoiceWhat they receiveValue
Refund now~$11,000 onceAnnuity rights for 14 years: voided
Deferred annuity at 621% × $98,000 × 14 = $13,720/yr for lifePays back the refund amount every ~10 months, then keeps paying
Deferred annuity at MRA (57), reduced$13,720 × (1 − 25% for 5 yrs under 62) ≈ $10,290/yrStarts 5 years earlier at a permanently lower rate

Illustrative: no cost-of-living adjustments (deferred annuities do receive COLAs once in payment), no survivor reduction. Even so, the shape is typical — the refund is the smallest number on the table by an order of magnitude.

Official documentation and references

Keep going

Educational disclaimer: This article is general education, not personalized financial, tax, legal, or benefits advice. Agency guidance, OPM publications, plan documents, and your official personnel records govern your situation. All numbers in examples are illustrative.