Why the headline number is the adjusted one

Run the default example above — a couple, both 62, $800,000 in traditional IRAs, $40,000 of other income in the gap years, $48,000 of Social Security from 70, filling the 12% bracket — and the raw totals say the ladder loses: $277,248.00 of lifetime tax with conversions against $231,907.48 without, a raw difference of −$45,340.52. A tool that stops there has just talked this couple out of a winning plan.

The raw comparison is rigged, in a specific way. Conversions move tax earlier: you pay part of the bill now, at a rate you chose, instead of later, at whatever rate your required distributions force. Counting only tax already paid credits the no-conversion path for a bill it has not paid yet — the $453,479.65 still sitting in the traditional IRA at 85, carrying $99,765.52 of embedded tax at the final year’s 22% rate. Charge each path for the tax still owed on the balance it leaves behind and the same example flips: the ladder saves $54,425.00. That adjusted figure is the headline on this page, and the results show both comparisons so you can watch the adjustment happen.

The adjustment is an approximation — the leftover would really be taxed across your remaining years, or your heirs’ brackets if they inherit it — but it compares the two paths on the same basis, which the raw figure does not. The full reasoning, with the strategy around it, is in the companion guide: The Roth Conversion Ladder, Year by Year.

How the schedule is built

Every year runs in the same order, because the tax code does: the required minimum distribution comes out first, on the prior year-end balance, once you reach your RMD age (72, 73, or 75 depending on birth year). The conversion then fills what is left of your ceiling — the smaller of your bracket headroom and, from 65, your IRMAA headroom — and never more than the balance that remains. Growth applies last, to what is left. Taxes are paid from money outside the IRA, so the full converted amount lands in the Roth; if you would pay the tax out of the conversion itself, your real benefit is smaller than shown.

Keep going

The strategy companion is The Roth Conversion Ladder, Year by Year; the shorter primer is Roth Conversions in the Gap Years, and Roth vs. Traditional covers the bracket question behind the timing. The surcharge side of the ceiling lives in IRMAA 2027, Explained, and the income the ladder leans on is in Your 2027 Social Security Raise, Net. Contribution room for the years before the ladder starts is in 2027 Contribution Limits.