A house is the largest thing most people ever inherit, and it arrives with a tax feature no other asset quite matches: the stepped-up basis. Under IRC §1014, inherited property takes a new cost basis equal to its fair market value at the owner's death (or an alternate valuation date six months later, if the estate elects it). Every dollar of appreciation during the owner's lifetime — often decades of it — simply never gets income-taxed. A house bought for $60,000 in 1985 and worth $520,000 at death carries a $520,000 basis into your hands. What you do next decides how much of that gift you keep.

First move: prove the value on the date of death

The step-up is only as good as your documentation. Get a date-of-death appraisal — or at minimum a broker's comparative market analysis in writing — while the estate is being settled, even if you plan to keep the house forever. Years later, when you sell, the IRS will ask what the house was worth when you inherited it, and "we think about $480,000" is a weaker answer than a licensed appraisal dated that spring. Estates sometimes skip this because no tax is due at inheritance. The bill for skipping it arrives at your sale, in the form of capital-gains tax on appreciation that was never yours.

Option 1: Sell it

Selling soon after inheriting is the tax-cheapest exit most heirs will ever be offered. Your gain is the sale price minus your stepped-up basis minus selling costs — on a prompt sale, usually close to zero, sometimes a small deductible loss if the market dipped. The real costs of this option are not taxes; they are commissions, closing costs, and the carrying costs of the months between death and closing (mortgage payments if any, insurance, utilities, property tax). If the house will sit empty, tell the insurer — vacant-home coverage is different, and a claim on a policy that assumed occupancy is a bad surprise. For most heirs who do not want the house, the sequence is: appraisal, settle title, sell. The step-up does the rest.

Option 2: Keep it and live in it

Move in, and the house becomes your home with a basis of its date-of-death value. Appreciation from that point forward is yours to be taxed on — but the §121 home-sale exclusion shelters up to $250,000 of gain ($500,000 for a married couple filing jointly) once you have owned and lived in it for two of the five years before a sale. Note what does not transfer: the deceased owner's years of ownership do not count toward your exclusion, and neither does their unused exclusion, except in the specific case of a surviving spouse (below). Your clock starts when the house becomes yours.

Option 3: Keep it and rent it

Renting converts the inheritance into a business. Two basis consequences follow. Your depreciation schedule starts fresh from the stepped-up value (the building portion, not the land), which makes the early years of renting unusually tax-sheltered — the step-up pays you twice. And when you eventually sell, the depreciation you claimed is recaptured at up to 25%, on top of capital gains on appreciation above the stepped-up basis. Renting can be the right answer — it is the only option that turns the house into income — but price it as a landlord decision (vacancy, repairs, liability, your time), not as a default while you avoid deciding.

The traps that change the math

Community property doubles the step-up. In community-property states, a house owned as community property gets both halves stepped up when the first spouse dies — the surviving spouse takes a full new basis. In common-law states, only the deceased spouse's half steps up; the survivor's half keeps its original basis. This is why the spousal case is not automatically the best case, and why a surviving spouse in a common-law state who sells the family home soon after a death should compute the gain on the half-and-half basis rather than assuming zero.

Inheriting with siblings is a negotiation, not a tax event. Each heir takes the same stepped-up basis in their share. The friction is practical: one sibling wants to sell, one wants to keep, one lives in it. The clean resolutions are a buyout at appraised value (the keeping sibling buys the others' shares) or a sale and split. The ugly one is a partition action — a court-ordered sale — which exists as a last resort and mostly serves to make the negotiated options look attractive. Put the agreement in writing while everyone still agrees; the estate's paperwork is the cheapest lawyer you will ever hire. How the title itself passes — probate, a transfer-on-death deed, a trust — is the territory of TOD and POD Accounts and Will vs. Trust.

Accounts are not houses. The step-up applies to property, not to retirement accounts. An inherited IRA gets no basis step-up at all and comes with a 10-year distribution clock instead — the contrast is the lesson, and it is worked through in The Inherited IRA 10-Year Rule. Families routinely assume the two inheritances work alike; they are opposite regimes. Where a house fits in the overall sequence when money arrives — before or after debts, reserves, and investing — is the order of operations in A Windfall Arrives.

Official documentation and references

Keep going

Educational disclaimer: This article is general education, not personalized financial, tax, legal, or benefits advice. Primary sources, plan documents, and — for insurance and estate topics — your state's law and licensed professionals govern your situation. All numbers in examples are illustrative.