Leasing's sales pitch is one true sentence — "the payment is lower" — doing the work of a conclusion it doesn't support. In Q2 2026 the average lease payment was $617 against $765 for a new-car loan (Experian), a $148 gap that ads treat as savings. It is not savings. It is the absence of equity, and when you count the equity, the ranking flips. Here is the full comparison on one car, with every assumption on the table.

The test car and assumptions (kept identical for both paths).
MSRP $40,000 · negotiated price $38,000 for both · taxes excluded from both paths (lease tax treatment varies by state; purchase tax is priced in the calculator's loan mode).
LEASE: 36 months, 12,000 mi/yr, residual 58% of MSRP = $23,200, money factor 0.00200 (4.8% APR equivalent), $695 acquisition fee rolled in, $0 down, $350 disposition fee at turn-in.
BUY: $3,800 down (10%), finance $34,200 at 6.15% (Experian's prime new-car average) for 60 months = $663.57/mo.

Three years

The lease: adjusted cap cost $38,695, so depreciation is ($38,695 − $23,200) ÷ 36 = $430.42/mo and the rent charge is ($38,695 + $23,200) × 0.00200 = $123.79/mo — a payment of $554.21. Over 36 months plus the disposition fee: $20,301, and you own nothing.

The purchase: after 36 payments the loan balance is $14,949 and the car is worth $23,200 (the same value the lessor's residual predicted), so you hold $8,251 of equity. Net cost: $3,800 + (36 × $663.57) − $8,251 = $19,438.

3-year verdict: buying is ~$864 cheaper in net cost — despite a payment $109/month higher. The lease's lower payment was never a lower cost; it was rent on depreciation with no asset at the end.

Six years

Leasing for six years means two back-to-back leases: $40,603, and you still own nothing (though you were always under warranty, in a new car). Buying costs $3,800 + (60 × $663.57) = $43,614 in cash out — minus the car's year-6 value, assumed at 40% of MSRP = $16,000 — for a net cost of $27,614, owning the car free and clear.

6-year verdict: buying wins by ~$12,989. Years 4–6 of ownership are the cheapest motoring there is — no payment, a depreciating-but-serviceable asset — and leasing never lets you have them.

Who leasing actually suits

Leasing wins the math in a narrow set of honest cases: you would genuinely replace a purchased car every three years anyway (then the real comparison is lease vs buy-and-trade-at-3, where the gap narrows to roughly the $864 above plus transaction costs); you can expense the lease through a business; or you knowingly pay a premium for always-new, always-warrantied driving and count it as consumption, not savings. It also suits drivers who stay well under the mileage cap — excess miles at $0.15–$0.30 each are a turn-in ambush. What leasing never wins on is the argument it is sold on: the lower payment. If a salesperson's case for the lease is the monthly number, you now know which half of the ledger they are showing you.

Two structural notes. GAP coverage is typically included free in leases from major captives (the lessor owns the car) — on a loan it is a paid add-on. And the lease's end is a decision point with fees attached: disposition ($350–$400 typical), excess wear, and mileage overages all price the exit. Our money factor guide decodes the lease's interest rate — the one number your contract is not required to state.

Use the calculator's Compare mode with your own MSRP, price, and money factor — the defaults are this article's test car, so you can reproduce every number above before changing a single input.

Official documentation and references

Keep going

Educational disclaimer: This article is general education, not personalized financial, tax, legal, or benefits advice. Primary sources, plan documents, and — for insurance and estate topics — your state's law and licensed professionals govern your situation. All numbers in examples are illustrative unless sourced and dated.