Losing a job deletes your health insurance on a schedule, and hands you two ways to buy it back. COBRA continues your employer's exact plan — same doctors, same deductible already partly met — at the full premium plus 2%, which is to say at a price that shocks everyone who never saw the employer's share before. The Marketplace sells you a new individual plan, potentially with a premium tax credit recalculated on your suddenly lower income. Both doors have clocks on them, and the clocks are the first thing to understand — because the smart play often uses the timing rules themselves.
The two clocks
- COBRA election: 60 days. Your former employer (if it has 20+ employees) must offer continuation coverage; you have at least 60 days from the notice to elect it, and coverage is retroactive to the day you lost it if you elect and pay. Continuation generally runs up to 18 months for a job loss.
- Marketplace special enrollment: 60 days. Losing job-based coverage is a qualifying life event; you have 60 days from the loss to enroll in a Marketplace plan (you can start the process up to 60 days before the loss if you know it is coming).
The retroactivity creates the famous gambit: a healthy person can wait inside the COBRA election window, uninsured on paper, and elect COBRA retroactively only if something expensive happens — paying the premiums back to day one. It is legal, it is common, and it is genuinely risky in one specific way: it depends on you (or someone acting for you) completing the election correctly while possibly injured or hospitalized. Treat it as a calculated bridge for the healthy and organized, not as free insurance.
Pricing COBRA: the full premium, and what it buys
COBRA's price is the full premium — yours plus the employer's share — plus a 2% administration charge. For a single employee whose paycheck showed a $150 deduction, the real premium might be $750; COBRA is about $765 a month. Families routinely see $1,800–$2,200. What that money buys: the identical plan, the identical network, and — mid-year, this is the sleeper benefit — credit for every dollar of deductible and out-of-pocket spending you have already accumulated. A household that has already met a $3,000 deductible in March and loses coverage in April is not comparing premiums; it is comparing COBRA against a Marketplace plan where the deductible starts over at zero. Price the remaining year, not the monthly sticker.
Pricing the Marketplace: the subsidy changes the math
Marketplace premiums are set against your projected income for the year — and a job loss slashes that projection. The premium tax credit can cut a benchmark silver plan's cost dramatically for a household now living on one income or on savings; some households qualify for cost-sharing reductions on silver plans that lower the deductible itself. The cautions: estimate income carefully (the credit reconciles on your tax return — overestimate your income drop and you may repay some credit), confirm your doctors are in the new network before you need them, and remember the deductible restarts. Also check the other doors before either of these: a spouse's employer plan (job loss is a special-enrollment trigger there too — our Split-or-Join framework prices joining), Medicaid if income has fallen far enough (enrollment is year-round), and — for federal employees — TCC, the FEHB parallel to COBRA, which runs on strikingly similar math.
The exit accounts: HSA and FSA on the way out
- Your HSA is yours. It leaves with you, stays invested, and can pay COBRA and Marketplace premiums tax-free — one of the few premium types HSA money can legally cover (it can pay health premiums while you receive unemployment benefits, too).
- Your health FSA mostly does not leave with you. Unspent FSA money is generally forfeited at separation unless you elect COBRA for the FSA itself (rarely worth it) — which is why the spending-down sprint in your final weeks matters. The spousal trap that links FSAs and HSAs is covered in Your Spouse's FSA Can Kill Your HSA.
A decision order that works
- Note both 60-day deadlines on a calendar the day coverage ends.
- If you are mid-treatment or your deductible is largely met, price COBRA first — continuity is probably the bargain.
- If you are healthy and your income has dropped hard, price the Marketplace with the subsidy — the gap is often hundreds a month.
- Check a spouse's plan and Medicaid before paying either sticker.
- Whichever you choose, choose before day 60 — after that, the choice makes itself.
Job loss is a coverage problem stacked on an income problem. For the income side — what to pay first when the money itself gets tight — the triage order is in When You Can't Cover Essentials + Minimums, and the full federal-employee version of the separation sequence is the Separation Money Checklist.
While the coverage decision runs on its 60-day clock, file the unemployment claim in the first week — the base period and the waiting week mean the check is later and smaller than most people expect. Unemployment Benefits, Explained covers how your state sets the amount and what can cut it off.
Official documentation and references
- U.S. Department of Labor — COBRA: election windows, 102% premium, 18-month duration
- HealthCare.gov — special enrollment after losing job-based coverage (60 days)
- HealthCare.gov — premium tax credits and cost-sharing reductions, keyed to projected income
- IRS — Publication 969: HSAs (yours to keep; premiums payable while on COBRA or unemployed) and FSAs (use-it-or-lose-it)
Keep going
- FEHB After You Leave: The 31-Day Extension, TCC Math, and the 5-Year Rule
- Your Spouse's FSA Can Kill Your HSA
- Leaving Federal Service: The Separation Money Checklist
- When You Can't Cover Essentials + Minimums: A Triage Order That Protects the Roof First
Educational disclaimer: This article is general education, not personalized financial, tax, legal, or benefits advice. Primary sources, plan documents, and — for insurance and estate topics — your state's law and licensed professionals govern your situation. All numbers in examples are illustrative.